A prospective multicenter and real-world study on the diagnostic value of combination of number connection test-B and line tracing test in mild hepatic encephalopathy
10.3760/cma.j.cn311367-20220606-00271
- VernacularTitle:数字连接试验-B联合轨迹描绘试验对轻微肝性脑病诊断价值的前瞻性、多中心、真实世界研究
- Author:
Junqing YAN
1
;
Hongmei ZU
;
Jing WANG
;
Xiaoqing GUO
;
Xiaoyan LI
;
Shanghao LIU
;
Huiling XIANG
;
Zhaolan YAN
;
Tong DANG
;
Haiying WANG
;
Jia SUN
;
Lei HUANG
;
Fanping MENG
;
Qingge ZHANG
;
Guo ZHANG
;
Yan HUANG
;
Shaoqi YANG
;
Shengjuan HU
;
Jigang RUAN
;
Yiling LI
;
Chuang LEI
;
Ying SONG
;
Zhangshu QU
;
Ruichun SHI
;
Qin LIU
;
Yijun LIU
;
Qiaohua YANG
;
Xuelan ZHAO
;
Caiyan ZHAO
;
Chenxi WU
;
Qian SHEN
;
Manqun WU
;
Yayuan LIU
;
Dongmei YAN
;
Chuan LIU
;
Junliang FU
;
Xiaolong QI
Author Information
1. 天津市第三中心医院消化肝病科 天津市重症疾病体外生命支持重点实验室 天津市人工细胞工程技术研究中心 天津市肝胆疾病研究所，天津 300170
- Keywords:
Liver cirrhosis;
Minimal hepatic encephalopathy;
Psychometric hepatic encephalopathy score;
Number connection test-B;
Line tracing test
- From:
Chinese Journal of Digestion
2022;42(10):659-666
- CountryChina
- Language:Chinese
-
Abstract:
Objective:To investigate the diagnostic value of independent and combined subtests of the psychometric hepatic encephalopathy score (PHES) in mild hepatic encephalopathy(MHE) of patients with liver cirrhosis, so as to optimize the PHES.Methods:This was a prospective, multicenter and real-world study which was sponsored by the National Clinical Research Center of Infectious Diseases and the Portal Hypertension Consortium. Twenty-six hospitals from 13 provinces, autonomous regions and municipalities countrywide participated in this study, induding Tianjin Third Central Hospital, the Fourth People′s Hospital of Qinghai Province, the Second Affiliated Hospital of Baotou Medical College, the Third People′s Hospital of Taiyuan, the Fifth Medical Center of PLA General Hospital and so on. From October 2021 to February 2022, outpatients and hospitalized patients with liver cirrhosis and no obvious hepatic encephalopathy were consecutively enrolled. All patients received 5 PHES subjects in the same order: number connection test(NCT)-A, NCT-B, digit symbol test(DST), line tracing test(LTT) and serial dotting test(SDT), and the scores were calculated. The total score of PHES <-4 was taken as the cut-off value for diagnosing MHE. Compare the differences in each subtest between MHE group and non-MHE group. Receiver operating characteristic curve(ROC) and area under the curve(AUC) was performed to assess the diagnostic value of independent and combined subtests in MHE. Mann-Whitney U test and DeLong test were used for statistical analysis. Results:A total of 581 patients with liver cirrhosis were enrolled, 457 were diagnosed as MHE, and the incidence of MHE was 78.7%. The results of NCT-A, NCT-B, SDT, LTT, DST of MHE group were 60.00 s(47.01 s, 88.00 s), 90.45 s(69.32 s, 125.35 s), 74.00 s(57.65 s, 96.60 s), 74.72(60.00, 98.61) and 27.00(20.00, 36.00), respectively. Compared those of non-MHE group(34.00 s(29.15 s, 44.48 s), 50.00 s(40.98 s, 60.77 s), 50.00 s(41.07 s, 63.03 s), 46.23(38.55, 59.42) and 42.00(34.00, 50.75)), the differences were statistically significant( Z=12.37, 12.98, 9.83, 11.56, 10.66; all P<0.001). The AUC(95% confidence interval(95% CI)) of subtests of PHES NCT-B, NCT-A, LTT, DST and SDT alone in MHE diagnosis were 0.880(0.849 to 0.910), 0.862(0.828 to 0.896), 0.838(0.799 to 0.877), 0.812(0.772 to 0.851) and 0.788(0.743 to 0.832), respectively. The combination of 2 PHES subtests significantly increased the diagnostic efficacy. Among them the diagnostic efficacy of the combination of NCT-B and LTT was the best, the AUC(95% CI) was 0.924(0.902 to 0.947), the specificity was 91.9% and the sensitivity was 79.2%, which was better than a single PHES subtest (NCT-A, NCT-B, SDT, LTT and DST) and the combination of NCT-A and DST(AUC was 0.879, 95% CI0.847 to 0.910) which was recommended by guidelines on the management of hepatic encephalopathy in cirrhosis, the differences were statistically significant ( Z=3.78, 3.83, 5.57, 5.51, 5.38, 2.93; all P<0.01). Furthermore, compared between the combination of NCT-B and LTT and the combination of 3 subests of PHES, only the diagnostic efficacy of combination of NCT-B, LTT and SDT (AUC was 0.936, 95% CI 0.916 to 0.956) was better than that of the combination of NCT-B and LTT, the difference was statistically significant( Z=2.32, P=0.020). Conclusion:Based on the diagnostic efficacy and clinical feasibility of PHES subtests and their combinations, the combination of NCT-B and LTT is recommended for the diagnosis of MHE.
