Evaluation of Five User-Friendly Whole Genome Sequencing Software for Mycobacterium tuberculosis in Clinical Application
10.3346/jkms.2022.37.e328
- Author:
Namhee KIM
1
;
Kwang Hyuk SEOK
;
Soyoun SHIN
;
Boram KIM
;
Hyunwoong PARK
;
Eun Youn ROH
;
Jong Hyun YOON
;
Sue SHIN
Author Information
1. Department of Laboratory Medicine, Seoul Metropolitan Government-Seoul National University Boramae Medical Center, Seoul, Korea
- Publication Type:Original Article
- From:Journal of Korean Medical Science
2022;37(46):e328-
- CountryRepublic of Korea
- Language:English
-
Abstract:
Background:Whole genome sequencing (WGS) is an increasingly useful tool for tuberculosis (TB) diagnosis and disease management. In this study, we evaluated the utility of userfriendly WGS tools in reporting resistance profiles and identifying lineages of clinical TB isolates from South Korea.
Methods:Forty clinical samples from TB patients showing discrepancies between their rapid molecular and conventional drug susceptibility tests were used in this study. Among these clinical isolates, 37 strains were successfully evaluated via WGS software, using the GenTB, TB Profiler, PhyResSE, CASTB, and Mykrobe.
Results:More accurate and faster susceptibility results could be obtained with isoniazid than with rifampin. Using the phenotypic test as the gold standard, the isoniazid concordance rate between phenotypic drug susceptibility test (DST) and WGS (GenTB: 45.9%, TB profiler: 40.5%, PhyResSE: 40.5%, CASTB: 48.6%, and Mykrobe: 43.2%) was much higher than between phenotypic DST and rapid molecular genotypic DST (18.9%) among the 37 strains.In contrast, the rifampin concordance rate between phenotypic DST and WGS and that between phenotypic DST and rapid molecular genotypic DST was similar (81.1–89.2%). We also found novel mutations associated with INH in katG and ahpC gene region, not covered by the line probe assay. In addition, lineage analysis identified 81.1% of these samples as L2 East Asian lineage strains, and 18.9% as L4 Euro-American lineage strains.
Conclusion:WGS may play a pivotal role in TB diagnosis and the detection of drug resistance, genetic diversity, and transmission dynamics in the near future because of its accuracy, speed, and extensibility.
