Variability in Management Practices and Surgical Decision Making in Spinal Tuberculosis: An Expert Survey-Based Study
- Author:
Kaustubh AHUJA
1
;
Tushar GUPTA
;
Syed IFTHEKAR
;
Samarth MITTAL
;
Gagandeep YADAV
;
Pankaj KANDWAL
Author Information
- Publication Type:Clinical Study
- From:Asian Spine Journal 2022;16(1):9-19
- CountryRepublic of Korea
- Language:English
-
Abstract:
Methods:Seventeen fellowship-trained spinal TB experts representing different geographical regions of India completed an online survey consisting of questions pertaining to the conservative management of spinal TB (antitubercular therapy) and 30 clinical case vignettes including a wide spectrum of presentations of spinal TB with no or minimal neurological deficit. The variability in the responses for questions and case wise variability with respect to surgical decision making was assessed using the index of qualitative variation (IQV). The average tendency to operate (TTO) was calculated for various groups of respondents.
Results:High variability was observed in all questions regarding conservative spinal TB management (IQV > 0.8). Among the 30 case vignettes, 14 were found to have high variability with respect to surgical decision making (IQV > 0.8). With respect to levels of fixation, all but two cases had poor or slight agreement. Younger age and practice in a government or tertiary care teaching hospital were factors associated with a higher TTO.
Conclusions:Significant variability was detected in treatment practices for the management of spinal TB among experts. Most of the case vignettes were found to have significant heterogeneity with respect to surgical decision making, which reflects a significant lack of consensus and lacunae in literature.
