Comparison of feasibility, time consumption and costs of three virtual planning systems for surgical correction of midfacial deficiency
10.1186/s40902-020-00284-1
- Author:
Katrin WILLINGER
1
;
Godoberto GUEVARA-ROJAS
;
Julia CEDE
;
Kurt SCHICHO
;
Tanja STAMM
;
Clemens KLUG
Author Information
1. University Clinic of Cranio- and Maxillofacial Surgery, Medical University of Vienna, Vienna, Austria.
- Publication Type:R E S E A R C H
- From:Maxillofacial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery
2021;43(1):2-
- CountryRepublic of Korea
- Language:English
-
Abstract:
Background:Today virtual surgical planning (VSP) is a standard method in maxillofacial corrective surgery and is the key to reach satisfactory esthetic outcomes. The purpose of this study was to evaluate usability of three established virtual surgical planning software applications by comparing feasibility, time consumption, and costs in a standardized workflow for a modified intraoral quadrangular Le Fort II osteotomy (IQLFIIO).
Results:A cross-sectional study was performed based on retrospective and re-planned data of patients with midfacial deficiency treated by modified IQLFIIO, using three software applications: IPS Case Designer ®, Dolphin Imaging®, and ProPlan CMF ®. Feasibility: All evaluated steps of the VSP procedure could be successfully performed in all three evaluated applications. In all software packages, it was possible to design the surgical splints with CAD/ CAM technology. Working time: The mean value of time needed was IPS Case Designe®, 36.5 min; Dolphin Imaging®, 33.6 min; ProPlan CMF®, 45.5 min. We found statistical significant difference between ProPlan CMF® and Dolphin Imaging® (p value, 0.02). Costs: Asset costs for acquiring the software, license fee, license possibilities, paying for support services, and service contracts were evaluated and are found in similar ranges.
Conclusion:All three tested software applications are usable for virtual planning of an IQLFIIO and splint production by CAD/CAM technology. Successful movement of bone segments and overlaying soft tissues proved feasibility. Time consumption and costs were found in similar ranges.
