Bayesian Network Meta-analysis of Therapeutic Efficacy and Safety of Chinese Patent Medicine Compound Preparation Combined with Conventional Therapy for Psoriasis Vulgaris
- VernacularTitle:中成药复方制剂联合常规治疗用于寻常型银屑病疗效与安全性的贝叶斯网状Meta分析
- Author:
Li LIN
1
;
Xiaoning YAN
2
;
Wenbin LI
2
;
Yiding ZHAO
2
Author Information
1. the First Clinical Medical College，Shaanxi University of TCM，Shaanxi Xianyang 712046，China
2. Dept. of Dermatology，Shaanxi Hospital of TCM，Xi’an 710003，China
- Publication Type:Journal Article
- Keywords:
Chinese patent medicine compound preparation;
Psoriasis vulgaris;
Bayesian network Meta-analysis;
Therapeutic
- From:
China Pharmacy
2021;32(6):750-757
- CountryChina
- Language:Chinese
-
Abstract:
OBJECTIVE：To systematically evaluate the therapeutic efficacy and safety of Chinese patent medicine compound preparation combined with conventional therapy for psoriasis vulgaris ，and to provide evidence-based reference for clinical drug use. METHODS ：Retrieved from CNKI ，Wanfang database ，VIP，CBM，PubMed，the Cochrane Library and Web of Science ， RCTs about Chinese patent medicine compound preparation combined with conventional therapy versus conventional therapy in the treatment of psoriasis vulgaris were collected during the inception to Feb. 2020. After literature retrieval and data extraction ，the quality of the included studies was evaluated with risk bias assessment tool recommended by the Cochrane evaluation manual handbook 5.1. Bayesian network Meta-analysis was perfor med by using Stata 15.0 software，Addis 1.16.6 software and Markov Chain Monte Carlo method. RESULTS ：A total of 41 RCTs were included ，involving 4 122 patients. 5 kinds of interven- tion measures included Compound qingdai capsule ，Xiaoyin SF-010） granule， Keyin pill ，Yujin yinxie tablet and conventional therapy. Results of network Meta-analysis showed that in terms of improving the total effective rate ， compared with conventional therapy ，4 kinds of Chinese patent medicine compound preparations combined with conventional therapy could significantly improve the total effective rate （P＜0.05）；the results of network Meta-analysis were as follows ：Keyin pill combined with conventional therapy ＞Compound qingdai capsule combined with conventional therapy ＞Xiaoyin granule combined with conventional therapy ＞Yujin yinxie tablet combined with conventional therapy ＞conventional therapy. In terms of reducing psoriasis area and severity index （PASI）score after treatment ，compared with conventional therapy ，Keyin pill and Xiaoyin granule combined with conventional therapy could significantly reduce the PASI score （P＜0.05），while Compound qingdai capsule and Yujin yinxie tablet combined with conventional treatment had no significant difference （P＞0.05）；the results of network Meta-analysis showed that Xiaoyin granule combined with conventional therapy ＞Keyin pill combined with conventional therapy ＞ Compound qingdai capsule combined with conventional therapy ＞Yujin yinxie tablet combined with conventional therapy ＞ conventional therapy. In terms of reducing serum inflammatory factor level ，compared with conventional therapy ，Compound qingdai capsule and Xiaoyin granule combined with conventional therapy could significantly reduce the level of IL- 17（P＜0.05）， but Keyin pill and Yujin yinxie tablet combined with conventional therapy had no significant difference （P＞0.05）；the results of network Meta-analysis showed that Xiaoyin granule combined with conventional therapy ＞Compound qingdai capsule combined with conventional therapy ＞Yujin yinxie tablet combined with conventional therapy ＞Keyin pill combined with conventional therapy＞conventional therapy. In terms of safety ，there was no statistical significance in the incidence of ADR between 4 kinds of Chinese patent medicine combined with conventional therapy and conventional therapy （P＞0.05）；the results of network Meta-analysis showed that Compound qingdai capsule combined with conventional therapy ＞Xiaoyin granule combined with conventional therapy ＞Keyin pill combined with conventional therapy ＞conventional therapy ＞Yujin yinxie tablet combined with conventional therapy . CONCLUSIONS ：Compared with conventional therapy ，additional use of 4 kinds of Chinese patent medicine compound preparations can improve the curative effect of psoriasis vulgaris patients with blood heat syndrome ，and Keyin pill is the best ；Xiaoyin granule is the best in reducing the degree of skin lesions and serum inflammatory factors ；additional use of 4 kinds of Chinese patent medicine compound preparations show good safety ，and Compound qingdai capsule is the best.
