Mini-invasive percutaneous plating of midshaft clavicle fractures with locking plate
10.3760/cma.j.cn121113-20200328-00192
- VernacularTitle:锁定钢板经皮微创内固定治疗锁骨中段骨折
- Author:
Wenwei DONG
1
;
Haijiao MAO
;
Zengyuan SHI
;
Liwei YAO
;
Zeting WU
Author Information
1. 宁波大学医学院附属医院创伤骨科 315000
- From:
Chinese Journal of Orthopaedics
2020;40(23):1601-1611
- CountryChina
- Language:Chinese
-
Abstract:
Objective:To introduce a new operative technique of mini-invasive plating of midshaft clavicle fractures with lateral clavicle anatomic locking plate and evaluate its clinical outcomes.Methods:From August 2017 to March 2019, 30 midshaft clavicular fracture patients were included in this study and retrospectively analyzed. There were 22 males and eight females with an average of 44.63±13.22 years (range 14-65 years). According to Robinson classification nine patients were classified as Type 2A2, 17 patients were classified as Type 2B1 and four patients were classified as Type 2B2. Before operation no symptoms of neurovascular injury was observed in this group. Operations were performed on an average of 2.33±1.75 d (range 0-7 d) after the injury. By comparing the injured clavicle lengths with the opposite healthy side pre and postoperatively on anteroposterior chest x-ray to evaluate the effect of indirect reduction. Shoulder function was evaluated using the Constant-Murley score at 6th month after the operation. Meanwhile, 32 patients with midshaft clavicular fracture treated with open reduction and internal fixation using clavicle reconstruction locking plate treated by the same group surgerons were compared in incision length, surgical duration, intraoperative fluoroscopy times, blood loss, fracture reduction, fracture healing time, Constant-Murley score and other complications. There were 25 males and seven females with an average of 42.63±14.18 years (range 16-70 years). According to Robinson classification six patients were classified as Type 2A2, 19 patients were classified as Type 2B1 and seven patients were classified as Type 2B2.Results:In mini-invasive group all patients were treated successfully with minimally invasive percutaneous osteosynthesis (MIPO) technique using lateral clavicle anatomic locking plate. The mean surgical duration was 63.40±7.82 minutes (range 48-92 min), The mean intraoperative fluoroscopy was 4.83±1.58 times (range 3-8 times). The mean blood lose was 15.67±4.13ml (range 10-30 ml). In open reduction group the mean surgical duration was 56.22±10.11 min (range 42-80 min), the mean intraoperative fluoroscopy was 3.91±1.49 times (range 2-5 times). The mean blood lose was 56.88±13.93 ml (range 40-100 ml). There was a significant difference in statistic by comparing surgical duration, intraoperative fluoroscopy times, blood loss ( P<0.05). In mini-invasive group the average proportional difference of the clavicular length was 12.15%±2.69% (range 5.2%-15.1%) preoperative and 0.45%±0.44% (range -0.2%-1.6%) postoperative comparing with the opposite healthy side, in open reduction group the average proportional difference of the clavicular length was 11.58%±2.67% (range 4.5%-16.1%) preoperative and 0.62%±0.41% (range -0.2%-1.2%) postoperative comparing with the opposite healthy side. There was no difference in statistic by comparing the fracture reduction in these two groups ( P>0.05). The mean follow-up period was 11.3±2.8 months (range 10-18 months) in mini-invasive group. Radiographic healing of the fracture was achieved at a mean time of 3.57±0.90 months (range 3-5 months). In open reduction group the mean follow-up period was 11.8±2.2 months (range 10-18 months), fracture healing time was 4.27±1.12 months (range 3-6 months), and there was significant difference in fracture union ( P<0.05). In mini-invasive group the mean total incision length was 2.8±0.48 cm (range 2.5-4.0 cm), no patient complained of numbness or paresthesia on subclavicular region or anterior chest wall, and all patients were satisfied with the cosmesis of the wounds and showed excellent shoulder joint function with a mean Constant-Murley score of 94.83±2.55 (range 89-97) at sixth month after the operation. In open reduction group the mean incision length was 11.0±1.08 cm (range 10-14 cm), 9 patients complained of numbness or paresthesia on subclavicular region or anterior chest wall, and only 5 patients were satisfied with the cosmesis of the wounds with a mean Constant-Murley score of 90.59±4.23 (range 78-97). There was a significant difference in statistic by comparing incision length, satisfactory cosmesis results, Constant-Murley score and paresthesia on subclavicular region ( P<0.05). Conclusion:Mini-invasive percutaneous plating of midshaft clavicle fractures with lateral clavicle anatomic locking plate is a good option for the treatment of midshaft clavicle fractures with satisfactory cosmesis results and excellent return to function.
