Comparison of long-term outcomes of different treatment for hepatolithiasis
- VernacularTitle:肝内胆管结石不同治疗方式长期疗效报告
- Author:
Lixin WANG
;
Zhi XU
;
Xiaofeng LING
- Publication Type:Journal Article
- Keywords:
Hepatolithiasis;
Hepatolobectomy;
Cholangiohepaticojejunostomy;
Hepaticoplasty
- From:
Chinese Journal of Minimally Invasive Surgery
2001;0(03):-
- CountryChina
- Language:Chinese
-
Abstract:
Objective To explore rational and effective treatment strategies by comparing long-term effects of different treatment methods for hepatolithiasis. Methods One hundred and fifty-nine cases of hepatolithiasis treated in this hospital from January 1993 to December 2002 were analyzed retrospectively.Five treatment methods: conservative treatment,choledocholithotomy followed by choledochostomy,hepatolobectomy,hepaticojejunostomy,and hepaticoplasty with the conservation of the Oddi's sphincter,were compared in respect of postoperative complications and long-term outcomes.Results Out of the 159 cases,follow-up was completed in 146 cases(91.8%,146/159) for 2~12 years(median,7 years).Of 16 cases of conservative treatment,15 were followed.Cholangitis occurred in all the 15 cases,with 1 fatal case.Of 47 cases of extrahepatic surgical exploration,the incidence of residual stones was 100%.Follow-up in 43 cases found 32 cases of cholangitis(74.4%) with 7 fatal cases.Of 16 cases of hepatolobectomy,residual stones were noted in 3 cases(12.5%).Follow-up in 15 cases found 4 cases of cholangitis(26.7%) with 1 fatal case.Of 32 cases of hepaticojejunostomy,residual stones were found in 11 cases(34.4%).Follow-up in 29 cases found 14 cases of cholangitis(48.3%) with 3 fatal cases.Of 48 cases of sphincter-sparing operation,residual stones were found in 8 cases(16.7%).Follow-up in 44 cases found 7 cases of cholangitis(15.9%).The incidence of residual stones was significantly higher in cases of extrahepatic surgical exploration than in cases of other treatment(P=0.000).The recurrence rate of cholangitis was significantly higher in cases of conservative treatment and extrahepatic surgical exploration than in cases of other treatment(P
