Efficacy comparison of different operations in treatment of papillary thyroid carcinoma
10.3969/j.issn.1671-8348.2014.17.005
- VernacularTitle:甲状腺乳头状癌不同术式的效果比较
- Author:
Li XIE
;
Ping ZHU
- Publication Type:Journal Article
- Keywords:
thyroid-neoplasms;
cervical-lymphadenectomy;
low-collar-incision;
L-shaped-incision;
life-quality
- From:
Chongqing Medicine
2014;(17):2124-2126,2129
- CountryChina
- Language:Chinese
-
Abstract:
Objective To compare the operative efficacy of low collar incision and L-shaped incision plus cervical plexus preser-ving lymphadenectomy in treating papillary thyroid carcinoma.Methods 9 3 inpatients with papillary thyroid carcinoma were ran-domly divided into the low collar incision group (n=37)and the L-shaped incision group(n=56)according to the random number table.The low collar incision group underwent the low collar type cervical plexus preserving lymphadenectomy,while the L-shaped incision group received the L-incision cervical plexus preserving lymphadenectomy.The postoperative 24-month follow up was per-formed.Then the clinical efficacy and the life quality of the patient were evaluated and compared between the two groups.Results (1)1 case of lymph node recurrence in the district Ⅱ after 20 months was found in the low collar incision group,1 case of lymph node recurrence in the district Ⅰ after 12 months and 1 case of lymph node recurrence in the districtⅣ after 22 months was found in the L-shaped incision group;no case of distant metastasis in the low collar incision group occurred during the follow up period, but 1 case of pulmonary metastasis in postoperative 5 months and 1 case of bone metastasis in postoperative 24 months occurred in the L-shpaed incision group.The differences in the occurrence rates of postoperative recurrence and metastasis had no statistical sig-nificance (2.70%vs.7.14%).(2)The scores of neck shoulder pain and numbness,incision appearance satisfaction degree in the low collar incision group were significantly higher than those of the L-shaped incision group (P<0.05).Conclusion Compared wtih L-shaped incision cervical lymphadenectomy,low collar incision cervical plexus preserving cervical lymphadenectomy has simi-lar high clinical efficacy,can significantly reduce neck shoulder pain and numbness,meet aesthetic requirements and especially is suitable for the patients with higher demands of the neck function preserving and the neck appearance.
