Comparison of efficacy and safety between the anterior and the posterior approaches to total hip arthroplasty
10.3969/j.issn.1671-167X.2017.02.004
- VernacularTitle:全髋关节置换术中直接前方入路与后外侧入路的疗效及安全性分析
- Author:
Yongjin ZHANG
;
Jia LI
;
Ke QI
;
Chenchen XUE
;
Weidong XU
- Keywords:
Hip joint;
Arthroplasty;
replacement;
hip;
Treatment outcome;
Direct anterior approach;
Posterior approach
- From:
Journal of Peking University(Health Sciences)
2017;49(2):201-205
- CountryChina
- Language:Chinese
-
Abstract:
Objective:To compare the efficacy and safety between direct anterior approach (DAA) and posterior approach (PA) in total hip arthroplasty.Methods: This study evaluated postoperative results of 92 consecutive total hip arthroplasties performed by a single surgeon;44 from the DAA,and 48 from PA.The age,body mass index,operation time,blood loss,hospital stay,positioning of the artificial hip,postoperative Harris score and postoperative complications were recorded and analyzed.Results: Both the average age of the patients separately (58.0±11.9) years in DAA group and (61.0±10.4) years in PA group and the body mass index (25.1±3.7) in DAA group and (24.7±3.3) in PA group,showed no significant difference between the two groups.The DAA group had significantly reduced the hospital stay (3.8±1.7) days vs.(4.9±2.3) days for the PA group (P<0.05) and operation time was (76.0±17.4) min in DAA group,and (71.0±14.3) min in PA group (P>0.05).The amount of blood loss: in group DAA (238.0±55.3) mL,and in group PA (387.0±61.2) mL (P<0.05).There was no statistical difference in the positioning of the artificial hip: the cup anteversion in DAA group and PA group was 17.3°±5.3° vs.18.6°±5.1°,the cup inclination was 38.5°±5.7° vs.37.7°±5.2°.In DAA group,there was significantly less use of assistive devices [(24.6±7.8) d vs.(31.7±10.2) d,P<0.05],and the pain was significantly lower.Harris score at the end of 6 weeks of the follow-up: in DAA group 85.7±5.4,and in PA group 81.3±6.1 (P<0.05);at the end of the last follow-up: in DAA group 93.4±4.7,and in PA group 92.3±5.3 (P>0.05).Complications were encountered in the two groups.There were two intraoperative complications (4.4％),1 great trochanter fracture and 1 lateral cutaneous nerve injury in DAA group.No dislocation was observed in DAA group.One dislocations and 1 groin pain were recorded in PA group.No prosthesis loosening,deep vein thrombosis,sciatic nerve injury and other complications occurred in the two groups.Conclusion: Total hip arthroplasty using the anterior approach allows for superior recovery and better stability.
