Dosimetric comparison between intensity-modulated radiotherapy and conformal radiotherapy for up-per thoracic esophageal carcinoma
10.3969/j.issn.1002-3070.2014.01.007
- VernacularTitle:胸上段食管癌3D-CRT与IMRT的剂量学比较
- Author:
Fenxia LIU
;
Qianqian ZHAI
;
Xiaodong SUN
;
Huitao WANG
;
Qiang ZHANG
;
Yinliang WANG
- Publication Type:Journal Article
- Keywords:
Upper esophageal carcinoma;
Three-dimensional conformal radiotherapy;
Intensity-modu-lated radiotherapy;
Dosimetry
- From:
Practical Oncology Journal
2014;(1):34-38
- CountryChina
- Language:Chinese
-
Abstract:
Objective To compare the dosimetry between three -dimensional conformal radiotherapy (3DCRT)and intensity -modulated radiotherapy(IMRT)in the treatment of upper thoracic esophageal carcino-ma,and to provide references to choose radiotherapy program for clinical physician .Methods twenty-five cases with upper esophageal carcinoma (clinical stageⅠ~Ⅲstage)were treated by 3DCRT and IMRT at the concentra three-dimensional radiation treatment planning system .The different exposure doses between target area and effected organs were compared by dose volume histogram ( DVH) with the planed target volume ( PTV) ,which must reach 95% of the prescriptive doses.Results Two different radiotherapy plans of IMRT and 3DCRT:V95, (99.91 ±0.14)%,(95.73 ±4.14)% respectively,P<0.05;targeting maximum doses(Dmax)were(6658.26 ±215.29)cGy,(6 664.20 ±465.16)cGy,P>0.05;targeting minimum dose(Dmin)were(5 458.88 ±184.06) cGy,(4541.60 ±599.0)cGy,P<0.05;targeting average doses(Dmean)were(6 232.80 ±53.00)cGy and (6 105.78 ±163.34)cGy,P<0.05.CI values were (0.76 ±0.04) and(0.57 ±0.05),P<0.05;HI values were(1.07 ±0.02) and(1.12 ±0.06),P <0.05;Spinal cord maximum dose (3 889.68 ±712.69) cGy, (4 337.48 ±178.49)cGy,P<0.05;Lung V20(20.94 ±5.32)%,(21.90 ±6.94)%,P>0.05;Lung V10 (35.39 ±11.41)%,(29.0 ±8.80)%,P<0.05,Lung V5(44.95 ±15.55)%,(37.27 ±11.93)%,P<0.05. Conclusion Intensity-modulated radiotherapy is better than 3DCRT technology in showing PTV volume ,target conformal degrees and the mean index ,spinal cord protection ,However ,The risk of lung injury could be increased with the enlarged area of low -dose irradiation in lung .
