Systematic review of the pharmacological agents for infants in the treatment of gastroesophageal reflux
10.3760/cma.j.issn.1673-4912.2012.03.016
- VernacularTitle:婴幼儿胃食管反流病治疗药物的系统评价
- Author:
Qiyu LI
;
Xu MAO
- Publication Type:Journal Article
- Keywords:
Gastroesophageal reflux;
Drug therapy;
Meta-analysis;
Systematic review;
Infant
- From:
Chinese Pediatric Emergency Medicine
2012;19(3):268-271
- CountryChina
- Language:Chinese
-
Abstract:
ObjectiveThis system review for the medicine of children gastroesophageal reflux disease(GERD) will provide the latest evidence based medicine evidence for pediatric clinical medication.MethodsThe documents of randomized controlled clinical trials of children GERD,which had been published in domestic and foreign journals from the year 2000 to 2010,had been retrieved and screened by the study inclusion criteria.According to the Jadad evaluation questionaire,the documents' quality had been evaluated.The efficiency rates of treatment were calculated respectively by the merger of same medicines,and the meta-analysis of different drugs had been done for evaluating the effect of different pharmacological therapeutic agents.In addition,the adverse events occurred during treatment were analyzed.ResultsThere were 31 documents fitting inclusion criteria.2 015 cases of children ( 1039 cases in treatment groups and 976 cases in control groups) had been included in these randomized controlled clinical trials.In these documents the agents included:cisapride ( 18 articles ),erythromycin ( 8 articles ),motilium ( 5 articles ).The merger efficiency rates of these medicines were cisapride (93.43％ ),erythromycin (92.86％ ),motilium (93.06％) respectively.There were no significant difference in the efficiencies of the three drugs in the treatment of GERD ( P＞0.05 ).In addition,the results of meta-analysis about treatment inefficiency,used with the postures therapy and support therapy as controls,were cisapride OR=0.15 ( OR 95％ CI0.11～0.20),erythromycin OR =0.08 ( OR 95％ CI 0.04～0.14 ),motilium OR=0.03 ( OR 95％ CI 0.01～0.07).Furthermore,their adverse effect rates were cisapride 0.72％ ( diarrhea 0.58％,somnolence 0.14％ ),erythromycin 0.96％ ( drug rashes 0.48％,slight increase of GOT 0.48％ ),motilium 1.50％ (diarrhea 1.50％ ).ConclusionThe efficiencies of smaller doses of erythromycin were better than cisapride,and not better than motilium;but the adverse effect rates were better than cisapride,and not better than motilium.In summary,smaller doses of erythromycin is better currently in the treatment of GERD.Attention should be paid in the use of erythromycin,since it accounted for slight increases in GOT or drug rashes approximately.
