Calcium sulfate versus calcium phosphate in treating traumatic fractures
- VernacularTitle:医用硫酸钙与磷酸钙在创伤性骨缺损中的应用比较
- Author:
Lei DENG
;
Jing LI
;
Yangyong SHEN
- Publication Type:Journal Article
- From:
Chinese Journal of Tissue Engineering Research
2008;12(49):9783-9786
- CountryChina
- Language:Chinese
-
Abstract:
BACKGROUND:Source of bone for autografting,allografting and xenografting is insufficient.Moreover,immunoreaction,infection and re-fracture occur sometimes.As artificial bone substitute.calcium sulfate and calcium phosphate ate widely used in clinic.OBJECTIVE:To compare the curative effect between calcium sulfate(Stirnulan pellets)and calcium phosphate(Bio-Lu bioceramics)as bone substitutions in traumatic fractures.DESIGN.TIME AND SETTING:Randomized controlled observation was performed at the Department of Orthopedics,Beijing Xiyuan Hospital.China Academy of Chinese Medical Science between October 2004 and October 2007.PARTICIPANTS:Fifry patients with bone trauma-induced bone defect who needed bone grafting were selected and randomly divided into two groups:calcium sulfate(n=24)and calcium phosphate(n=26).METHODS:Besides internal fixation(steel-wire,plate)and external fixation(plaster,external frisket),all Cases were filled with bone substitutes.The grafted bone mass was on basis of standards of grafting:generally 3-5mL for Barton fracture and calcaneus fracture.the maximum 10 mL.MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES:Bone substitute usage,resorption time.fracture status and bone callus.RESULTS:All fractures that were filled with bone substitutes were healed well.No abnormal reaction occurred in calcium sulfate group.Two cases with calcium phosphate exhibited effusion in local soft tissue and healed by changing dressing.During the follow-up of 6 months(range 4-12 months),the bone substitutes were absorbed completely.The absorptivity of Stimulan pellets was 80%within 2 mortths and 100%within 3 months.faster than Bio.iu bioceramics(70%within 4-6months:90%within 7-12 mortths).CONCLUSION:The advantages of calcium sulfate and phosphate as bone substitutes are safety.convenience,and few side effects with good filling effect and well fractures healing.Moreover,the calcium sulfate powder(Stimulan)exhibits stronger supporting for bone defect area after soliditication,and faster degradation than calcium phosphate
