A controlled study on identification for depression and effectiveness of its treatment in psychiatric clinics of general hospitals
- VernacularTitle:上海市综合性医院精神科门诊医师对抑郁症识别及治疗的对照研究
- Author:
Zheng LU
;
Junjuan ZHU
;
Jun CAI
;
Yushan LI
;
Shenxun SHI
;
Yijue SHI
;
Chongshun WANG
;
Youqian JIANG
;
Jianlin JI
;
Rongshen ZHU
;
Hongyi HAN
;
Suju DING
- Publication Type:Journal Article
- Keywords:
Depressive disorder;
Diagnosis;
Treatment outcome:Psychiatric department,hospital
- From:
Chinese Journal of General Practitioners
2008;7(4):231-234
- CountryChina
- Language:Chinese
-
Abstract:
Objective The study is designed to evaluate the difference in identification for depression and clinical effectiveness of its treatment between psychiatrists and non-psychiatric Dhysieians at out-patient departments of general hospitals and to analyze its related factors.Methods Totally,680 patients who visited psychiatric clinics in nine general hospitals of Shanghai at first time were screened by psychiatrists using Composite International Diagnostic Interview(CIDI)for depression and the screening resuhs were compared to the diagnosis made by non-psychiatric physicians as goal-keepers there.Altogether 297 patients with depression were recruited and assessed using Hamilton Depression Rating Scale(HAMD)and Hamilton Anxiety Rating Scale(HAMA).A self-made questionnaire for basic information was used to assess the ability for identification of depression in non-psychiatric physicians of general hospitals.Results Psychiatrists identified depression correctly in 337 of 680 patients who visited psychiatric clinics in general hospitals at their first visit,but non-psychiatric physicians only identified 216 patients,with statistically significant difference(χ2=30.73,P=0.000).A consistent agreement on depression diagnosis between the findings by psychiatrists and by CIDI was reached with Kappa of 0.774,but Kappa for that between the findings by non-psychiatric physicians and CIDI was 0.439.Effectiveness of treatment for depression by psychiatrists was better than that by non-psychiatric physicians,with higher total score and scores for each item of HAMD four,eight and 12 weeks after treatment,respectively(P＜0.05 or P＜0.01).Length of professional work of non-psychiatric physicians and annual time for professional training in management of mental disorders associated with their ability of identification for depression(P＜0.05).Conclusion Ability of non-psychiatric physicians to identify alQd cope with depression in the psychiatric department of general hospitals was insufficient,suggesting that more importance should be attached to the management of service quality at psychiatric department of general hospitals.
