A questionnaire survey for orthopedists on the clinical experience of patients who suffered adverse events associated with acupuncture and moxibustion
10.3777/jjsam.64.54
- VernacularTitle:整形外科医を対象とした鍼灸に関連した有害事象患者の診療経験に関するアンケート調査
- Author:
Hisashi SHINBARA
;
Satomi NAGAOKA
;
Chie OGASAWARA
;
Kokoro HINO
;
Hiroshi TANIGUCHI
;
Eiji SUMIYA
- Publication Type:Journal Article
- Keywords:
acupuncture and moxibustion safety;
adverse events;
questionnaire survey;
orthopaedist;
safety measures
- From:Journal of the Japan Society of Acupuncture and Moxibustion
2014;64(1):54-64
- CountryJapan
- Language:Japanese
-
Abstract:
[Objective]The purpose of this study was to gain a clear understanding of adverse events associated with acupuncture (Acp) and moxibustion (Mox) therapies. Thus, we administered questionnaires to orthopedists in order to understand the clinical experience of patients who suffered adverse events.
[Materials and Methods]For this study, 6,000 orthopedic hospitals and clinics were randomly selected from 13,225 hospitals and clinics listed in the telephone directory iTown Page (http://itp.ne.jp). In October 2011 and July 2012, 3,500 and 2,500 questionnaires, respectively, were sent by mail. The questions addressed the following:(1) the respondent's profile (e.g., years of experience as a licensed orthopedist);(2) adverse events associated with Acp, including electroacupuncture;(3) adverse events associated with Mox;(4) use of Acp and Mox therapies in the orthopedist's hospital or clinic;(5) comments on the safety of Acp and Mox therapies. The identity of respondents remained secret.
[Results]The questionnaire response rate was 10.7%. The respondents were licensed orthopedists for 30 ± 11 years (mean ±standard deviation). Adverse events associated with Acp included retained needles and needle breakage (n ≥148), hemorrhages (n ≥ 64), infections (n ≥ 40), organ injuries (n = 28), and so on. Retained needles (≥ 145 out of 148), subcutaneous hemorrhages (63out of 64), arthritis (17 out of 40), and pneumothorax injuries (27 out of 28) occurred most frequently. The adverse events associated with Mox were burn injuries (n ≥ 121), infections (n ≥ 16), and other adverse events (n = 2). Second-degree burn injuries (n ≥ 48 out of 121) and suppuration infections (11 out of 16) occurred most frequently. These were the most common adverse events associated with Acp and Mox. The usage rate of Acp and Mox therapies in the orthopaedist's hospital or clinic was 18.6%. There were many comments on infection control by acupuncturists (n = 27), education and technical levels of Acp and Mox (n = 13), and retained needles and needle breakages (n = 13).
[Conclusion]These survey results reveal that the occurrence of severe adverse events associated with Acp and Mox was higher than our expectation. In order to improve the safety of Acp and Mox therapies, various educational activities to disseminate information about existing safety measures to acupuncturists are needed. Further studies on new preventive measures, continuous surveys, and feedback to acupuncturists are also required.
