Study of correlations between the examinees' results on the basic objective structured clinical examination (OSCE), computer-based testing, and the advanced OSCE
- VernacularTitle:共用試験ＯＳＣＥ，ＣＢＴとａｄｖａｎｃｅｄ ＯＳＣＥにおける評価の相関―同一の受験者での検討―
- Author:
Manabu MIYAMOTO
;
Shouichi SUGINO
;
Chikao SIMAMOTO
;
Hirohumi DEGUCHI
;
Yasusi KITAURA
;
Hiroshi YONEDA
- Publication Type:Journal Article
- Keywords:
Common Achievement Test;
correlation between objective structured clinical examinations and computerbased testing;
evaluation;
direct and indirect effects;
advanced OSCE
- From:Medical Education
2007;38(6):399-405
- CountryJapan
- Language:Japanese
-
Abstract:
Studying the correlation between the results of the Common Achievement Test (basic objective structured clinical examination [OSCE] and computer-based testing [CBT]) and the results of advanced OSCE in the same examinees is necessary to improve clinical clerkships and to establish the role of each examination.
1) Ninety-seven students took the Common Achievement Test CBT and the basic OSCE in their fourth year and took the advanced OSCE in their sixth year. The Common Achievement Test basic OSCE were composed of interview, chest, abdomen, neurology, and head and neck stations, and the CBT included blocks 1-4 and 5-6. The advanced OSCE had 3 scenarios in the chest station, 2 in the abdomen station, and 4 in the neurology station. Each scenario had 3 items. We also examined the pass analysis on the basis of these 3 items in the advanced OSCE.
2) The results of the Common Achievement Test basic OSCE interview did not correlate significantly with the results of the interview station of the advanced OSCE. The results of physical examinations in the Common Achievement Test basic OSCE, excluding the chest, did not correlate significantly with the results of the physical examination stations of the advanced OSCE.
3) In the advanced OSCE, an adequate medical interview is necessary for the physical examination. An adequate physical examination is also necessary for answering the written tests (e.g., differential diagnosis). 4) Students should have sufficient basic knowledge and motivation for successfully performing clinical clerkships, because the correlations among the results of the advanced OSCE interview, the OSCE total score, the Common Achievement Test basic OSCE and CBT score were extremely strong.
5) The advanced OSCE, the Common Achievement Test basic OSCE, and CBT have distinct characteristics and roles.
