In vitro evaluation of accuracy and consistency of four different electronic apex locators.
10.5395/JKACD.2006.31.5.390
- Author:
Jae Hyun CHO
1
;
Kee Yeon KUM
;
Seung Jong LEE
Author Information
1. Department of Conservative Dentistry, Oral Science Research Center, Yonsei University, Seoul, Korea. sjlee@yumc.yonsei.ac.kr
- Publication Type:In Vitro ; Original Article
- Keywords:
Electronic apex locator;
Consistency;
Accuracy;
Alginate model;
Major foramen;
Apical constriction
- MeSH:
Bicuspid;
Constriction;
Tooth
- From:Journal of Korean Academy of Conservative Dentistry
2006;31(5):390-397
- CountryRepublic of Korea
- Language:Korean
-
Abstract:
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the accuracy and the consistency of four different electronic apex locators in an in vitro model. Fourty extracted premolars were used for the study. Four electronic apex locators (EAL) were Root ZX, SmarPex, Elements Diagnostic Unit (EDU), and E-Magic Finder Deluxe (EMF). After access preparation, the teeth were embedded in an alginate model and the length measurements were carried out at "0.5"and "Apex"mark using four EALs. The file was cemented at the location of the manufacturers'instruction (Root ZX, EDU, EMF: 0.5 mark, SmarPex: Apex mark). The apical 4mm of the apex was exposed and the distance from the file tip to the major foramen was measured by Image ProPlus (x 100). The distance from the file tip to the major foramen was calculated at 0.5 and Apex mark and the consistency of 0.5 and Apex mark was compared by SD and Quartile of Box plots. In this study, Root ZX and EMF located the apical constriction accurately within +/- 0.5 mm in 100%, whereas SmarPex and EDU located in 90% and in 70% respectively. For Root ZX and EMF, there was no significant difference between the consistency of 0.5 and Apex mark. However, for the EDU and SmarPex, Apex mark was more consistent than 0.5 mark. From the evaluation of the consistency in this study, for Root ZX and EMF, both 0.5 and Apex mark can be used as a standard mark. And for EDU and SmarPex, the Apex mark can be recommended to be used as a standard mark.
