Medico-Legal Consideration of Hemopneumothorax : Closing Claim Study.
- Author:
Hyuna BAE
1
;
Young Jin CHEON
Author Information
1. Department of Medical Law & Ethics, Yonsei University College of Medicine, Korea.
- Publication Type:Original Article
- Keywords:
Pneumothorax;
Hemothorax;
Complication;
Malpractice
- MeSH:
Cause of Death;
CD-ROM;
Hemopneumothorax*;
Hemothorax;
Humans;
Informed Consent;
Jurisprudence;
Malpractice;
Pneumothorax;
Retrospective Studies;
Supreme Court Decisions
- From:The Korean Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery
2006;39(2):117-126
- CountryRepublic of Korea
- Language:Korean
-
Abstract:
BACKGROUND: The purpose of this study is to describe the characteristics of malpractice claims related to hemopneumothorax and to identify the causes and potential preventability of such claims. MATERIAL AND METHOD: A retrospective study was performed by reviewing the records in the Lawnb website and Lx CD-rom: the records on closed malpractice claims involving hemopneumothorax were abstracted from the files available for analysis. The records were reviewed and were analysed to determine the etiology of hemopneumothorax, patient age, results of lawsuit and indemnity payment, underlying diseases, cause of death or complications, and the factors associated with a successful defense. RESULT: Seven closed claim involving hemopneumothorax were founded in the data for malpractice. Three claims were supreme court decision, one was a high court decision and three claims were district court decision. The most common cause of death was tension pneumothorax. Four of which resulted in indemnity payments. CONCLUSION: While malpractice claims involving hemopneumothorax were uncommon, they resulted in a high rate and amount of indemnity payments. Claims are more common in pediatric patients. In case of iatrogenic hemopneumothorax, post-procedural X-ray can improve patient outcome and is also associated with decreased indemnity risks. Informed consent is also important.
