Development of a Core Outcome Set for Clinical Evaluation of Chronic Pulmonary Heart Disease Treated with Traditional Chinese Medicine Therapy
10.13288/j.11-2166/r.2025.12.007
- VernacularTitle:中医药治疗慢性肺源性心脏病临床评价核心指标集的构建
- Author:
Baihan NIU
1
;
Mingyan ZHANG
2
;
Zhaochen JI
2
;
Bo PANG
2
;
Haiyin HU
2
;
Junhua ZHANG
2
Author Information
1. The First Affiliated Hospital of Henan University of Chinese Medicine，Zhengzhou，450000
2. Tianjin University of Traditional Chinese Medicine
- Publication Type:Journal Article
- Keywords:
chronic pulmonary heart disease;
traditional Chinese medicine therapy;
core outcome set;
clinical evaluation;
methodology
- From:
Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine
2025;66(12):1227-1232
- CountryChina
- Language:Chinese
-
Abstract:
ObjectiveTo construct an outcome set for clinical evaluation of traditional Chinese medicine （TCM） for chronic pulmonary heart disease， and to provide consensus outcomes for the evaluation of the clinical effectiveness of TCM for chronic pulmonary heart disease. MethodsWe searched randomised controlled trials of TCM for chronic pulmonary heart disease on China National Knowledge Infrastructure （CNKI）， Wanfang Data Knowledge Service Platform （WF）， VIP Chinese Science Journals Database （VIP）， Chinese Biomedical Literature Service Database （SinoMed）， PubMed， Cochrane Library， and Embase. We also searched Chinese Clinical Trial Registry Platform and the U.S. Clinical Trial Registry database to obtain the outcome indicators reported in the clinical research protocols of TCM for chronic pulmonary heart disease. The outcome indicators were also collected through semi-structured interviews of clinicians and patients. Then integrated the outcome indicators collected by the above methods to construct the indicator pool. Through two rounds of Delphi surveys and a consensus conference， the core outcome set for clinical evaluation of TCM for chronic pulmonary heart disease was determined. ResultsAfter screening， there were 1313 literature meeting the criteria， and 595 outcome indicators were extracted， then combined with the outcomes from semi-structured interviews which clinicians and patients concerned， finally an indicator item pool containing 369 outcome indicators were formed. After the initial screening of indicators in the pool by the steering committee， 58 indicators were established into the initial list of indicator entries. In the first round of Delphi survey， the expert coordination coefficient for the results was 0.401， and the Cronbach coefficient was 0.989. A total of 35 indicators that did not meet the criteria ［＜70% of the participants rated the outcome as 7~9 （critical） and the mean of the expert ratings ＜7］ were deleted， and 23 were retained， with 7 new indicators added that were open to supplementation by the experts， resulting in a total of 30 indicators that were included in the second round of Delphi survey. In the second round of Delphi survey， the expert coordination coefficient was 0.303， and the Cronbach coefficient was 0.974， with a total of 7 indicators that did not meet the criteria being deleted， and 21 indicators being retained for the consensus conference. After the consensus meeting， the core outcome set for clinical evaluation of chronic pulmonary heart disease in two major categories， acute exacerbation stage and stable stage， was finally determined， in which there were four indicators in acute exacerbation stage： N-terminal B-type natriuretic peptide precursor （NT-proBNP）， blood qi analysis， all-cause mortality rate， and complication rate； and there were eight indicators in the stable stage： pulmonary function index， six-minute walk test distance， New York cardiac function classification， all-cause mortality rate， re-hospitalisation rate， Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Assessment Test （CAT） score， Short Form 36 Health Survey （SF-36）， and TCM syndrome score. ConclusionThe core outcome sets of TCM clinical evaluation in the acute exacerbation stage and stable stage are constructed， which is helpful to improve the practicability， comparability and transparency of TCM clinical research results in pulmonary heart disease.
