The Journal Impact Factor: Moving Toward an Alternative and Combined Scientometric Approach.
10.3346/jkms.2017.32.2.173
- Author:
Armen Yuri GASPARYAN
1
;
Bekaidar NURMASHEV
;
Marlen YESSIRKEPOV
;
Elena E UDOVIK
;
Aleksandr A BARYSHNIKOV
;
George D KITAS
Author Information
1. Departments of Rheumatology and Research and Development, Dudley Group NHS Foundation Trust (Teaching Trust of the University of Birmingham, UK), Russells Hall Hospital, Dudley, West Midlands, UK. a.gasparyan@gmail.com
- Publication Type:Editorial
- Keywords:
Journal Impact Factor;
Periodicals as Topic;
Editorial Policies;
Publishing;
Publication Ethics;
Science Communication
- MeSH:
Complement System Proteins;
Editorial Policies;
Humans;
Journal Impact Factor*;
Periodicals as Topic;
Proxy;
Publications;
Social Media
- From:Journal of Korean Medical Science
2017;32(2):173-179
- CountryRepublic of Korea
- Language:English
-
Abstract:
The Journal Impact Factor (JIF) is a single citation metric, which is widely employed for ranking journals and choosing target journals, but is also misused as the proxy of the quality of individual articles and academic achievements of authors. This article analyzes Scopus-based publication activity on the JIF and overviews some of the numerous misuses of the JIF, global initiatives to overcome the ‘obsession’ with impact factors, and emerging strategies to revise the concept of the scholarly impact. The growing number of articles on the JIF, most of which are in English, reflects interest of experts in journal editing and scientometrics toward its uses, misuses, and options to overcome related problems. Solely displaying values of the JIFs on the journal websites is criticized by experts as these average metrics do not reflect skewness of citation distribution of individual articles. Emerging strategies suggest to complement the JIFs with citation plots and alternative metrics, reflecting uses of individual articles in terms of downloads and distribution of related information through social media and networking platforms. It is also proposed to revise the original formula of the JIF calculation and embrace the concept of the impact and importance of individual articles. The latter is largely dependent on ethical soundness of the journal instructions, proper editing and structuring of articles, efforts to promote related information through social media, and endorsements of professional societies.
