Correct the Mistake of Attributing the Authorship of Wenbing Zhinan and Yixue Zhenchuan to GAO Bingjun
10.16466/j.issn1005-5509.2024.05.021
- VernacularTitle:《温病指南》《医学真传》作者误为高秉钧之正讹
- Author:
Yuanye GU
1
;
Weixuan JI
;
Yiliang XIONG
Author Information
1. 北京中医药大学 北京 100029
- Keywords:
Wenbing Zhinan;
Yixue Zhenchuan;
GAO Bingjun;
LOU Jie;
GAO Shishi;
citation chains;
error;
Zhonghua Yidian
- From:
Journal of Zhejiang Chinese Medical University
2024;48(5):642-648
- CountryChina
- Language:Chinese
-
Abstract:
[Objective]To sort out and correct the transmission context of the mistaken authorship of Wenbing Zhinan(Guide to Warm Diseases)and Yixue Zhenchuan(Medical Secrets)as being by GAO Bingjun.[Methods]Through the method of character verification,a literature verification and sorting is conducted on the individuals and events of GAO Bingjun,LOU Jie and GAO Shishi.Through the method of literature retrieval,academic papers and monographs with errors in Wenbing Zhinan and Yixue Zhenchuan are retrieved from China National Knowledge Infrastructure(CNKI)and Duxiu databases.Through the method of bibliometrics,the CNKI literature co-citation network analysis tool is used to analyze the citation network of erroneous references in Yixue Zhenchuan.[Results]Based on the biographical information of GAO Bingjun,LOU Jie and GAO Shishi,it was known that they specialized in different fields and their birth-death dates did not overlap.According to the research papers and monographs indicating errors in transmission context,it was suggested that the source upstream of errors in Wenbing Zhinan and Yixue Zhenchuan should be attributed to the 2002 edition electronic book Zhonghua Yidian(Chinese Medical Records).The results from network analysis indicated that a paper titled"Theoretical Study on Warming and Dredging Function of Moxibustion"published in 2011,played a significant role in promoting the spread of errors regarding authors'mistakes in Yixue Zhenchuan.[Conclusion]The author of Wenbing Zhinan was LOU Jie and the author of Yixue Zhenchuan was GAO Shishi respectively.These two books were mistakenly attributed to GAO Bingjun due to scholars'failure to carefully verify original documents during citations.This suggests that researchers must exercise caution when citing sources to avoid perpetuating errors.
