Comparison of biomechanical characteristics of five internal fixation methods for the treatment of Seinsheimer type V subtrochanteric fractures of the femur
10.3760/cma.j.cn121113-20231030-00263
- VernacularTitle:五种内固定方式治疗SeinsheimerⅤ型股骨转子下骨折的生物力学特性比较
- Author:
Zhi XU
1
;
Yuwan LI
;
Ziming LIU
;
Min YANG
Author Information
1. 张家港市第五人民医院骨科，张家港 215600
- Keywords:
Femoral fractures;
Internal fixators;
Finite element analysis;
Biomechanical phenomena
- From:
Chinese Journal of Orthopaedics
2024;44(9):616-625
- CountryChina
- Language:Chinese
-
Abstract:
Objective:To conduct a comparative analysis of the biomechanical properties of Seinsheimer type V subtrochanteric femoral fractures treated with different fixation methods, including proximal femoral locking plate, Cephalomedullary nail + plate, Cephalomedullary nail + titanium cable, reconstructive intramedullary nail + plate, and reconstructive intramedullary nail+titanium cable, using finite element analysis.Methods:CT scan data of the left femur from a healthy adult volunteer was obtained and utilized to create a finite element model of Seinsheimer V subtrochanteric femoral fracture through software simulation. The construction of femoral proximal locking plates, cephalomedullary nails, reconstructive intramedullary nails, steel plates, and titanium cable internal fixation devices was based on manufacturer-provided product manuals. Following the assembly of fracture and internal fixation components, comparisons were made under physiological loads regarding the maximum displacement, maximum stress, and stress excitation effects on fracture fragments and internal fixation components across the various fixation models.Results:The maximum displacements of the femoral proximal locking plate, cephalomedullary nail + plate, cephalomedullary nail+titanium cable, reconstructive intramedullary nail+plate, and reconstructive intramedullary nail+titanium cable were 7.9, 5.7, 4.3, 4.3, and 4.9 mm, respectively. The maximum displacements of the internal fixation systems were 7.4, 5.8, 4.3, 4.3, and 4.9 mm, respectively. The maximum torsion angles of the internal fixation systems were 1.8°, 1.5°, 1.4°, 1.3°, and 1.5°, respectively. The maximum stresses on the fracture fragments of the femoral proximal locking plate were 172.0, 114.1, 115.4, 93.5, and 118.5 MPa, respectively. The maximum stresses on the internal fixation systems were 4,530.0, 993.6, 1,179.0, 890.4, and 847.2 MPa, respectively. The maximum contact stress on the contact surfaces of the distal and proximal fracture contact surface of the medial wall, and the distal and proximal fracture contact surface of the lateral wall of the proximal femoral locking plate was 48.9, 37.9, 4.4, 18.7 MPa, which was the highest among the five fixation methods, respectively. The contact stress of the cephalomedullary nail+titanium cable on contact surfaces mentioned above was 16.1, 18.1, 6.9, 11.7 MPa, exceeding the 0.0, 0.0, 5.5, 7.5 MPa of the cephalomedullary nail+plate. The contact stress of the reconstructive intramedullary nail+titanium cable on contact surfaces mentioned above was 13.7, 13.4, 6.9, 14.1 MPa, exceeding the 0.0, 0.0, 5.6, 11.0 MPa of the reconstructive intramedullary nail + plate as well.Conclusion:The utilization of the reconstructive intramedullary nail + titanium cable fixation method for treating Seinsheimer type V subtrochanteric femoral fractures demonstrates superior performance in terms of structural stability, durability, and stress stimulation on the bone cortex.
