Simulation study on missing data imputation methods for longitudinal data in cohort studies
10.3760/cma.j.cn112338-20201130-01363
- VernacularTitle:队列研究中纵向缺失数据填补方法的模拟研究
- Author:
Yemian LI
1
;
Peng ZHAO
;
Yuhui YANG
;
Jingxian WANG
;
Hong YAN
;
Fangyao CHEN
Author Information
1. 西安交通大学医学部公共卫生学院流行病与卫生统计学系 710061
- Keywords:
Longitudinal data;
Missing data;
Imputation
- From:
Chinese Journal of Epidemiology
2021;42(10):1889-1894
- CountryChina
- Language:Chinese
-
Abstract:
Objective:Data being missed is an unavoidable problem in cohort studies. This paper compares the imputation effect of eight common missing data imputation methods involved in cutting longitudinal data through simulation study to provide a valuable reference for the treatment of missing data in longitudinal studies.Methods:The simulation study is based on R language software and generates missing longitudinal data by the Monte Carlo method. By comparing the average absolute deviation, average relative deviation, and TypeⅠerror from the regression analysis of different imputation methods, the imputation effect of varying imputation methods on missing longitudinal data and the influence on subsequent multivariate analysis are evaluated.Results:The mean imputation, k nearest neighbor (KNN), regression imputation, and random forest all have a similar imputation effect, which is also steady. However, the hot deck is inferior to the above imputation methods. K-means clustering and expectation maximization (EM) algorithm are among the worst and unstable. Mean imputation, EM algorithm, random forest, KNN, and regression imputation can control TypeⅠerror. Still, multiple imputations, hot deck, and K-means clustering cannot effectively manage the TypeⅠerror.Conclusions:For missing data in longitudinal studies, mean imputation, KNN, regression imputation, and random forest can be used as better imputation methods under the mechanism of missing at random. When the missing ratio is not too large, multiple imputations and hot deck can also perform well, but K-means clustering and EM algorithm are not recommended.
