Scientific Publication Speed of Korean Medical Journals during the COVID-19 Era
10.4258/hir.2024.30.3.277
- Author:
Hyeonseok SEO
1
;
Yaechan KIM
;
Dongryeong KIM
;
Hanul KANG
;
Chansu PARK
;
Sejin PARK
;
Junha KANG
;
Janghyeog OH
;
Hyunsung KANG
;
Mi Ah HAN
Author Information
1. Department of Premedicine, Chosun University College of Medicine, Gwangju, Korea
- Publication Type:Original Article
- From:Healthcare Informatics Research
2024;30(3):277-285
- CountryRepublic of Korea
- Language:English
-
Abstract:
Objectives:This study compared the scientific publication speeds of Korean medical journals before and during the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) era.
Methods:We analyzed 2,064 papers from 43 international Korean medical journals, selecting 12 papers annually from 2019 to 2022. We assessed publication speed indicators, including the time from submission to revision and from submission to publication. Additionally, we examined variations in publication speed based on journal and paper characteristics, including whether the studies were related to COVID-19.
Results:Among the 43 journals analyzed, 39.5% disclosed the peer review duration from submission to the first decision, and 11.6% reported their acceptance rates. The average time from submission to acceptance was 127.0 days in 2019, 126.1 days in 2020, 124.6 days in 2021, and 126.4 days in 2022. For COVID-19-related studies, the average time from submission to revision was 61.4 days, compared to 105.1 days for non-COVID-19 studies; from submission to acceptance, it was 87.4 days for COVID-19-related studies and 127.1 days for non-COVID-19 studies. All indicators for COVID-19-related studies showed shorter durations than those for non-COVID-19 studies, and the proportion of studies accepted within 30 or 60 days was significantly higher for COVID-19-related studies.
Conclusions:This study investigated the publication speed of Korean international medical journals before and during the COVID-19 pandemic. The pandemic influenced journals’ review and publication processes, potentially impacting the quality of academic papers. These findings provide insights into publication speeds during the COVID-19 era, suggesting that journals should focus on maintaining the integrity of their publication and review processes.
