Design Diagram：A Framework for Visualizing Study Designs Using Real-world Data and Improving Study Reproducibility
- VernacularTitle:デザインダイアグラム：リアルワールドデータを活用した研究デザインを可視化し，再現性を高めるフレームワーク
- Author:
Toshiki FUKASAWA
1
;
Masao IWAGAMI
2
;
Azusa HARA
3
;
Hisashi URUSHIHARA
4
Author Information
- Keywords: study design; reproducibility; database study; design diagram; real-world data
- From:Japanese Journal of Pharmacoepidemiology 2023;28(2):39-55
- CountryJapan
- Language:Japanese
- Abstract: There is growing interest in generating evidence from routinely collected real-world data to support medical and regulatory decision-making. However, longitudinal study designs using real-world data are often complex, and text-only descriptions make it difficult for most readers to understand their designs. To address this issue, in 2019, experts from industry, government, and academia developed the “design diagram,” a framework for visualizing longitudinal study designs. The design diagram uses standardized terminology and a graphical structure to communicate study design details to readers, thereby improving reproducibility. Based on previous work by a joint task force between the International Society for Pharmacoepidemiology (ISPE) and the Professional Society for Health Economics and Outcomes Research (ISPOR), the diagram includes a comprehensive set of key study parameters related to reproducibility. It successfully presents study designs in an unambiguous and intuitive manner. Diagrams have been proposed for various study designs, including cohort, nested case-control, and self-controlled designs. Recently, a new diagram was developed that adds at-a-glance elements to show the observability of the source data used in the study. The use of design diagrams is recommended in both the ISPE/ISPOR-endorsed harmonized protocol template (HARPER) and in reporting guidelines for pharmacoepidemiological research, and its widespread use is expected. This paper describes the structure of the design diagram and provides examples of its use. Effective use of design diagrams is expected to improve the reproducibility and reliability of database studies.
