BACKGROUND

Diabetes mellitus (DM) is a significant and growing global health concern. Worldwide, 537 million adults have diabetes and 206 million of them are from the Western Pacific Region1. Local prevalence continues to remain high at 7.5%, with 4,303,899 adult Filipinos suffering from diabetes in 2021. DM significantly contributes to the growing burden of chronic kidney disease (CKD) worldwide with about 50% of end-stage renal disease (ESRD) being due to diabetic nephropathy alone. Likewise, 60% of Filipinos on maintenance dialysis have ESRD due to DM and hypertension. The primary care setting is the initial point of contact between healthcare providers and patients with type 2 diabetes, hence, the development of clinical practice guidelines that will provide guidance in caring for patients with stable complications of diabetes. The guideline is the first of 3 that are being developed by the Philippine Academy of Family Physicians for the diagnosis and management of adult patients with type 2 diabetes and stable microvascular complications – nephropathy, retinopathy and neuropathy.

OBJECTIVE

This guideline aims to provide evidence-based recommendations on the diagnosis and management of adults with type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) and early stage CKD and is divided into 5 main sections – Clinical Assessment, Diagnostic Tests, Pharmacologic Treatment, Non-pharmacologic Treatment and Patient Outcomes.

METHODS

The method of guideline development followed the ADAPTE process. The Technical Working Group identified 19 key questions after consultation with colleagues and patients. Recommendations were adopted from high-quality clinical practice guidelines whenever applicable for most of the key clinical questions. On the other hand, the De Novo method of evidence review was used to answer key clinical questions for which recommendations from reviewed guidelines were not available. A modified GRADEPro was used in assessing the quality of evidence – high, moderate, low or very low. Following external review by a nephrologist, the draft recommendations were sent to the members of the consensus panel. Voting on whether to include or not by the consensus panel was facilitated to determine the strength of each recommendation – strong, moderate or weak.

RECOMMENDATIONS

After reviewing 3 high-quality clinical practice guidelines and the current evidence, the technical working group was able to develop 40 recommendations for the 19 key clinical questions.

Human ; Diabetes Mellitus, Type 2 ; Kidney Failure, Chronic ; Practice Guideline

practice guideline ; literature ; diagnosis ; endometriosis

Clinical practice guideline is defined as “statements that include recommendations intended to optimize patient care that are informed by a systematic review of evidence and an assessment of the benefits and harms of alternative care options”. It includes recommendations that are intended to optimize patient care. They are the best source of evidence for busy clinicians and may be the most efficient type of evidence to guide decision making in family practice.
Practice Guideline

Objective: To determine the rate of the appropriateness of the requested CT and MRI procedures in the Outpatient Department of a tertiary hospital in the Philippines from January to June 2018 using the American College of Radiology Appropriateness Criteria (ACR-AC).

Methods: This retrospective research reviewed outpatient CT and MR imaging requests and cross-referenced with the corresponding ACR-AC guideline available for the written clinical diagnosis.

Results: Four hundred thirty-six (436) (56%) of the 774 retrieved requests were CT scan studies, while the remaining 338 (44%) are MR imaging procedures. Cross-referencing with ACR-AC, the rate of appropriateness across all patients is high at 96.6%, with a 95% confidence interval of 95.0% and 97.6%. The rates were not significantly different between MRI and CT (p-value = 0.4502). Likewise, there was no significant difference in rates of appropriateness for the body parts abdomen, cranial, chest, and spine (p-value = 0.6502).

Conclusion: Although the results were high, relative to the few available international studies, the importance and potential of the ACR-AC cannot be disregarded. The ACR-AC serves as a guide in selecting the appropriate imaging test given a clinical situation. This may equate to better patient management, considering all patient-related factors.

Key Words: diagnostic imaging; reviews, appropriateness; practice guideline

Diagnostic Imaging ; Practice Guideline

Background. A 2017 situational analysis assessing Clinical Practice Guidelines (CPG) development in the Philippines revealed CPGs of inconsistent quality. In response, the Department of Health (DOH)-Philippine Health Insurance Corporation Manual for CPG Development was developed to outline the standardized steps of the CPG development process. To implement this, technically qualified institutions and individuals should be commissioned.

Objective. To identify qualified institutions and individuals and map out their technical skills and potential for capacit building in CPG development

Methods. Mixed methods were used in this cross-sectional study. A snowballing method identified specific institutions and individuals. Self-administered surveys and key informant interviews were conducted to determine competence, strengths, and gaps in the development of CPGs.

Results. A total of 74 individuals from 45 institutions with competencies in CPG development were identified. Of the 45 institutions, 72% were non-clinical, with roughly half working on formal research. Of the 74 individuals, 96% possessed relevant knowledge and skills and 85% already provided training on CPG development topics. Around half of the respondents have been part of a CPG development task force. Only about half were able to incorporate social concepts of equity, and only one-third had experience in managing conflicts of interest.

Conclusion. Qualified institutions and individuals identified in this capacity mapping can be tapped in future CPG development in the country. Incorporation of social concepts and management of conflicts of interest still need to be ensured.

Practice Guideline ; Capacity Building

INTRODUCTIONThis study aimed to evaluate compliance with and performance of the Canadian Computed Tomography Head Rule (CCHR), and its applicability to the Singapore adult population with minor head injury.

METHODSWe conducted a retrospective study over six months of consecutive patients who presented to the adult emergency department (ED) with minor head injury. Data on predictor variables indicated in the CCHR was collected and compliance with the CCHR was assessed by comparing the recommendations for head computed tomography (CT) to its actual usage.

RESULTSIn total, 349 patients satisfied the inclusion criteria. Common mechanisms of injury were falls (59.3%), motor vehicle crashes (16.9%) and assault (12.0%). 249 (71.3%) patients underwent head CT, yielding 42 (12.0%) clinically significant findings. 1 (0.3%) patient required neurosurgical intervention. According to the CCHR, head CT was recommended for 209 (59.9%) patients. Compliance with the CCHR was 71.3%. Among the noncompliant group, head CT was overperformed for 20.1% and underperformed for 8.6% of patients. Multivariate logistic regression analysis revealed that absence of retrograde amnesia (odds ratio [OR] 4.1, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.8-9.7) was associated with noncompliance to the CCHR. Factors associated with underperformance were absence of motor vehicle crashes as a mechanism of injury (OR 6.6, 95% CI 1.2-36.3) and absence of headache (OR 10.8, 95% CI 1.3-87.4).

CONCLUSIONCompliance with the CCHR for adult patients with minor head injury remains low in the ED. A qualitative review of physicians' practices and patients' preferences may be carried out to evaluate reasons for noncompliance.

Accidental Falls ; Accidents, Traffic ; Adult ; Aged ; Canada ; Craniocerebral Trauma ; diagnostic imaging ; Decision Making ; Decision Support Systems, Clinical ; Electronic Health Records ; Female ; Glasgow Coma Scale ; Guideline Adherence ; Head ; diagnostic imaging ; Humans ; Male ; Middle Aged ; Multivariate Analysis ; Odds Ratio ; Practice Patterns, Physicians' ; Retrospective Studies ; Tomography, X-Ray Computed ; Violence

Clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) have become ubiquitous in every field of medicine today but there has been limited success in implementation and improvement in health outcomes. Guidelines are largely based on the results of traditional randomised controlled trials (RCTs) which adopt a highly selective process to maximise the intervention's chance of demonstrating efficacy thus having high internal validity but lacking external validity. Therefore, guidelines based on these RCTs often suffer from a gap between trial efficacy and real world effectiveness and is one of the common reasons contributing to poor guideline adherence by physicians. "Real World Evidence" (RWE) can complement RCTs in CPG development. RWE-in the form of data from integrated electronic health records-represents the vast and varied collective experience of frontline doctors and patients. RWE has the potential to fill the gap in current guidelines by balancing information about whether a test or treatment works (efficacy) with data on how it works in real world practice (effectiveness). RWE can also advance the agenda of precision medicine in everyday practice by engaging frontline stakeholders in pragmatic biomarker studies. This will enable guideline developers to more precisely determine not only whether a clinical test or treatment is recommended, but for whom and when. Singapore is well positioned to ride the big data and RWE wave as we have the advantages of high digital interconnectivity, an integrated National Electronic Health Record (NEHR), and governmental support in the form of the Smart Nation initiative.
Big Data ; Electronic Health Records ; Evidence-Based Medicine ; Guideline Adherence ; Humans ; Practice Guidelines as Topic ; Practice Patterns, Physicians' ; Pragmatic Clinical Trials as Topic ; Precision Medicine ; Singapore

BACKGROUND: Despite the availability of clinical guidelines for stroke, variation exists in the management patterns of stroke among neurologists.
OBJECTIVE: To determine the current practice patterns of Filipino adult neurologists in stroke and their adherence to the current clinical guidelines of the Stroke Society of the Philippines (SSP).
METHODS: Cross-sectional survey using a 3-page, 17-item questionnaire reviewed by the Stroke Council of the Philippine Neurological Association (PNA).
RESULTS AND OBSERVATIONS: From November 2013 to July 2014, 136 of 277 (49%) locally practicing board certified adult neurologists of the PNA were surveyed. Some important findings from the survey include: (1) 70% of respondents underestimated the benefit of warfarin in stroke prevention in nonvalvular atrial fibrillation (NVAF); (2) for acute ischemic stroke, although the recommended systolic blood pressure (SBP) threshold is >220 mm Hg, 43% would initiate antihypertensive therapy at SBP >180 mm Hg; (3) for acute primary intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH), 42% would start antihypertensives at SBP >140 mm Hg; (4) despite the absence of guidelines recommending the use of neuroprotectant drugs for acute stroke, 75% and 56% of neurologists have prescribed it to >80% of their patients with infarcts and ICH respectively; (5) 46% of neurologists have not experienced giving thrombolytic therapy to any of their patients with acute ischemic stroke; (6) among patients with clinically stable hemorrhagic strokes, 77% of neurologists would give antithrombotics, while 28% of them would start it 30 days after the onset of stroke; (7) only 21% of respondents have ordered carotid studies as part of their work up in >80% of their patients with ischemic strokes; and (8) 64% of respondents have requested carotid revascularization procedures for patients with significant carotid stenosis, and about 38% of these patients underwent the procedure.
CONCLUSION: The management patterns in stroke remain varied among Filipino neurologists, although the patterns show increasing adherence toward guideline recommendations. The following practices are noted: underestimation of the benefits of oral anticoagulation for stroke prevention among patients with NVAF; use of pharmacologic control of blood pressure below the recommended threshold for acute ischemic stroke; widespread use of neuroprotectant drugs despite lack of definite evidence for its use; low utilization of carotid studies in the work-up of patients with ischemic stroke and the low rate of revascularization procedures in confirmed cases of carotid stenosis; and a relative increase in experience with thrombolysis.

Practice Guideline ; Surveys and Questionnaires ; Stroke

The standardized hypertension management provided by primary health care workers is an important part of China's recent health care reform efforts. Investigating 5,116 hypertensive patients from a cross-sectional survey conducted by the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention in 2012, this study found that adherence to standardized hypertension management is associated with positive effects on hypertension- related knowledge, healthy lifestyle behavior, antihypertensive medical treatments, and blood pressure control. It will be necessary to provide primary health care workers with sufficient training and reasonable incentives to ensure the implementation and effectiveness of hypertension management.
Adult ; Aged ; Aged, 80 and over ; China ; Cross-Sectional Studies ; Female ; Guideline Adherence ; statistics & numerical data ; Health Care Reform ; legislation & jurisprudence ; Health Care Surveys ; Health Knowledge, Attitudes, Practice ; Healthy Lifestyle ; Humans ; Hypertension ; psychology ; therapy ; Male ; Middle Aged ; Patient Compliance ; psychology ; statistics & numerical data

Administration, Inhalation ; Adrenal Cortex Hormones ; therapeutic use ; Adrenergic beta-Agonists ; therapeutic use ; Anti-Asthmatic Agents ; therapeutic use ; Antibodies, Monoclonal, Humanized ; therapeutic use ; Asthma ; prevention & control ; therapy ; Guideline Adherence ; Humans ; Molecular Targeted Therapy ; Muscarinic Antagonists ; therapeutic use ; Omalizumab ; therapeutic use ; Practice Guidelines as Topic ; Primary Prevention ; Quality Improvement ; Sublingual Immunotherapy